gtk+3-3.20.6

[bdubbs@…]

New point version. Can't they get this right?

Answer: NO. This is buggy. Waiting for next release.

[Douglas R. Reno]

Cosmetic insertion of line

Overview of Changes in GTK+ 3.20.5
==================================

* Bugs fixed:
 763852 gdk/wayland: event source is not multi-thread aware
 765973 GtkRevealer need to always send "child-revealed" signal...
 766175 Translation of quotes may misinterpreted by GTK sidebar
 766233 Crash when server does not support XI2
 766440 Scale slider button has stopped discerning & rendering...
 766442 Broken drag & drop between windows

* Translation updates:
 Kazakh
 Portuguese

I would say not... I would think that "Drag and Drop between windows" and slider buttons would be tested before releasing a new version.

[bdubbs@…]

The package buids fine, but I got 15 failures in the regression tests. I checked in xfce, but I don't know if that is enough. All the failures seemed to resolve around ui issues:

c.log:  /properties/GtkFileChooserButton:                                 FAIL
c.log:  /properties/GtkFileChooserDialog:                                 FAIL
c.log:  /properties/GtkFileChooserWidget:                                 FAIL
c.log:  /properties/GtkPlacesSidebar:                                     FAIL
c.log:FAIL: object
c.log:  /tmp/gtk3/gtk+-3.20.5/testsuite/a11y/menu.ui:                     FAIL
c.log:  /tmp/gtk3/gtk+-3.20.5/testsuite/a11y/menubutton.ui:               FAIL
c.log:  /tmp/gtk3/gtk+-3.20.5/testsuite/a11y/menubutton2.ui:              FAIL
c.log:  /tmp/gtk3/gtk+-3.20.5/testsuite/a11y/menubutton3.ui:              FAIL
c.log:  /tmp/gtk3/gtk+-3.20.5/testsuite/a11y/scale-drawvalue.ui:          FAIL
c.log:  /tmp/gtk3/gtk+-3.20.5/testsuite/a11y/tooltips.ui:                 FAIL
c.log:FAIL: accessibility-dump
c.log:  /tmp/gtk3/gtk+-3.20.5/testsuite/reftests/inherit-and-initial.ui:  FAIL
c.log:  /tmp/gtk3/gtk+-3.20.5/testsuite/reftests/textview-margins.ui:     FAIL
c.log:FAIL: gtk-reftest

Perhaps it needs a different DE. Can anyone else check? Other than the checks, It seems to be OK and I'm ready to commit.

[Douglas R. Reno]

I can test on LXDE later on tonight / tomorrow. I could test on GNOME3 sometime in the next week, but I don't think you want to wait for that long. I can try some GTK3 based applications too. Those failures worry me, especially if accessibility is broken, objects (FileChooser) are broken, etc.

[bdubbs@…]

A week will not hurt us. This is not time critical.

[Pierre Labastie]

I have lxde and lxqt available. I have a lot more errors than you, but I get the exact same errors under lxqt as under lxde...

[Pierre Labastie]

Tests are as bad (not that bad, actually, only 47 FAIL for 2335 OK) under 3.20.4.

[bdubbs@…]

I retried in a system with gcc5. The tests in /properies/ above pass and inherit-and-initial.ui also passes. There were no additional failures.

The typical failure was reasonably cossistent and looked like:

/tmp/gtk3/gtk+-3.20.5/testsuite/a11y/tooltips.ui:                    Contents don't match expected contents:
--- /tmp/gtk3/gtk+-3.20.5/testsuite/a11y/tooltips.txt 2016-03-25 21:46:38.000000000 -0500
+++ /tmp/.7NH8GY  2016-05-20 17:01:38.979133352 -0500
@@ -7,14 +7,6 @@
   <AtkComponent>
   layer: window
   alpha: 1
-  unnamed-GtkContainerAccessible-0
-    "panel"
-    parent: window1
-    state: enabled sensitive showing visible
-    toolkit: gtk
-    <AtkComponent>
-    layer: widget
-    alpha: 1
   box1
     "filler"
     parent: window1
FAIL

So it looks like some kind of panel thing to me. I suspect the tests need more of gnome than what we have in the book.

[Douglas R. Reno]

Check this out

​https://bugzilla.gnome.org/show_bug.cgi?id=766694

[Douglas R. Reno]

​https://git.gnome.org/browse/gtk+/commit/?h=gtk-3-20&id=ca8d51e6d0f78cc170cc212dd7ef6664d2e662f4

[bdubbs@…]

I'm thinking we should mark this as wontfix and wait for the next version. I'd expect that fairly soon. What do you think?

[Douglas R. Reno]

I would be for that. With how much is broken, I don't want to mess with that at the moment.

[Douglas R. Reno]

Now 3.20.6

​http://ftp.gnome.org/pub/GNOME/sources/gtk+/3.20/gtk+-3.20.6.news

Overview of Changes in GTK+ 3.20.6
==================================

* Bugs fixed:
 766694 crash on save as in any gtk3 application starting 3.20.5...
 766323 GTKPopover gives warnings if visible when reparented
 766336 Crash when selecting rows with rubberbanding
 766737 stack: Only map children when necessary

* Translation updates:
 Arabic

[Douglas R. Reno]

Seems that they fixed those bugs. Should I take this one and do it with GNOME?

[bdubbs@…]

Replying to renodr:

Seems that they fixed those bugs. Should I take this one and do it with GNOME?

If you want, take it. However, it seems that you are a bit overloaded right now. There is not a great hurry however.

[Douglas R. Reno]

Fixed at r17542