Wrong input for wget-list in Makefile

[thomas]

In the Makefile there is the section

wget-list: $(BASEDIR)/wget-list
$(BASEDIR)/wget-list: stylesheets/wget-list.xsl chapter03/chapter03.xml \
                      packages.ent patches.ent
        @echo "Generating consolidated wget list at $(BASEDIR)/wget-list ..."
        $(Q)mkdir -p $(BASEDIR)

        $(Q)xsltproc --nonet --xinclude                    \
                --stringparam profile.revision $(REV) \
                --output $(RENDERTMP)/sysd-wget.xml   \
                stylesheets/lfs-xsl/profile.xsl       \
                chapter03/chapter03.xml

        $(Q)xsltproc --xinclude --nonet            \
                --output $(BASEDIR)/wget-list \
                     stylesheets/wget-list.xsl     \
                chapter03/chapter03.xml

shouldn't the last xslproc use "sysd-wget.xml" as input? It would than read as:

wget-list: $(BASEDIR)/wget-list
$(BASEDIR)/wget-list: stylesheets/wget-list.xsl chapter03/chapter03.xml \
                      packages.ent patches.ent
        @echo "Generating consolidated wget list at $(BASEDIR)/wget-list ..."
        $(Q)mkdir -p $(BASEDIR)

        $(Q)xsltproc --nonet --xinclude                    \
                --stringparam profile.revision $(REV) \
                --output $(RENDERTMP)/sysd-wget.xml   \
                stylesheets/lfs-xsl/profile.xsl       \
                chapter03/chapter03.xml

        $(Q)xsltproc --xinclude --nonet            \
                --output $(BASEDIR)/wget-list \
                     stylesheets/wget-list.xsl     \
                $(RENDERTMP)/sysd-wget.xml

A patch would look like:

--- Makefile.orig	2018-08-20 14:05:17.206025624 +0200
+++ Makefile	2018-08-20 14:05:55.919230588 +0200
@@ -167,7 +167,7 @@
 	$(Q)xsltproc --xinclude --nonet            \
                 --output $(BASEDIR)/wget-list \
 	             stylesheets/wget-list.xsl     \
-                chapter03/chapter03.xml
+                $(RENDERTMP)/sysd-wget.xml
 
 md5sums: $(BASEDIR)/md5sums
 $(BASEDIR)/md5sums: stylesheets/wget-list.xsl chapter03/chapter03.xml \

[Bruce Dubbs]

We purposely use the same list for both the systemd and System V books. For sysv, that means downloading two packages that are not used, systemd{,-manpages} and dbus. For sysd it means downloading eudev (and the Udev-lfs Tarball), lfs-bootscripts, sysklogd, and sysviinit.

The sizes of the extra files are small, about 9 MB for sysv and about 2 MB for systemd.

This gives flexibility to the user to build either book after a single wget. The consolidated set of packages is also available at different mirrors such as ​ftp://ftp.lfs-matrix.net/pub/lfs/lfs-packages/

The consolidated file is also used when running the daily currency checks.

[thomas]

Ok, understand that. But than, the output of the first xsltproc (xsltproc ... --output $(RENDERTMP)/sysd-wget.xml ...) is not used anywhere. At least not in the Makefile.

[Bruce Dubbs]

I do not have that. I don't have wget.xml anywhere in the Makefile.

wget-list: $(BASEDIR)/wget-list
$(BASEDIR)/wget-list: $(RENDERTMP)/$(BLFSFULL)
   @echo "Generating wget list for $(REV) at $(BASEDIR)/wget-list ..."
   $(Q)mkdir -p $(BASEDIR)
   $(Q)xsltproc --nonet                       \
                --output $(BASEDIR)/wget-list \
                stylesheets/wget-list.xsl     \
                $(RENDERTMP)/$(BLFSFULL)

[thomas]

​http://wiki.linuxfromscratch.org/lfs/browser/trunk/BOOK/Makefile line 161+

ah, just saw that apparently you looked in BLFS's Makefile. Here it is about the LFS's Makefile

[Bruce Dubbs]

Yes, I was looking at BLFS. I don't think the first xsltproc is needed. I'll comment it out.

[Bruce Dubbs]

Fixed at revision 11455.